Universal Rights and the Constitution by Stephen A. Simon

By Stephen A. Simon

Innovative exam of the tensions among common and extra uniquely American definitions of adored rights.

Are constitutional rights established solely in uniquely American concerns, or are they established no less than in half on ideas that go beyond the bounds of any specific state, equivalent to the necessities of freedom or dignity? by way of viewing constitutional legislations during the prism of this basic query, Universal Rights and the Constitution exposes an missed trouble with reviews rendered via the excellent court docket, particularly, an inherent ambiguity concerning the varieties of arguments that count number in constitutional interpretation, which weakens the principles of our so much loved rights.

Rejecting present debates over constitutional interpretation as unsuitable, Stephen A. Simon bargains an leading edge framework designed to supply clearer foundations for rights interpretations whereas conserving a significant yet restricted function for common arguments. He unearths the important connections between modern debates over such concerns because the correct to privateness, the constitutionality of the loss of life penalty, and the position of overseas legislations in constitutional interpretation

Show description

Read or Download Universal Rights and the Constitution PDF

Best civil rights books

Why We Can't Wait

Dr. King’s best-selling account of the civil rights circulate in Birmingham throughout the spring and summer season of 1963
On April sixteen, 1963, because the violent occasions of the Birmingham crusade spread out within the city’s streets, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. , composed a letter from his felony cellphone based on neighborhood non secular leaders’ feedback of the crusade. The ensuing piece of striking protest writing, “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” used to be largely circulated and released in different periodicals. After the realization of the crusade and the March on Washington for Jobs and Freedom in 1963, King extra constructed the information brought within the letter in Why We Can’t Wait, which tells the tale of African American activism within the spring and summer season of 1963. in this time, Birmingham, Alabama, used to be maybe the main racially segregated urban within the usa, however the crusade introduced through King, Fred Shuttlesworth, and others validated to the realm the facility of nonviolent direct action.
usually applauded as King’s such a lot incisive and eloquent booklet, Why We Can’t Wait recounts the Birmingham crusade in shiny element, whereas underscoring why 1963 was once one of these the most important 12 months for the civil rights flow. dissatisfied by way of the sluggish speed of college desegregation and civil rights laws, King saw that by means of 1963—during which the rustic celebrated the one-hundredth anniversary of the Emancipation Proclamation—Asia and Africa have been “moving with jetlike velocity towards gaining political independence yet we nonetheless creep at a horse-and-buggy velocity. ”
King examines the heritage of the civil rights fight, noting projects that destiny generations needs to accomplish to result in complete equality, and asserts that African americans have already waited over 3 centuries for civil rights and that it's time to be proactive: “For years now, i've got heard the be aware ‘Wait! ’ It jewelry within the ear of each Negro with piercing familiarity. This ‘Wait’ has in general intended ‘Never. ’ We needs to come to work out, with considered one of our unusual jurists, that ‘justice too lengthy behind schedule is justice denied. ’”

Free Speech on Trial: Communication Perspectives on Landmark Supreme Court Decisions

Describes landmark loose speech judgements of the ideally suited court docket whereas highlighting the problems of language, rhetoric, and verbal exchange that underlie them. on the intersection of verbal exchange and primary modification legislations stay major questions: what's the speech we should defend, and why may still we safeguard it?

Race, rights, and the Asian American experience

In Race, Rights, and the Asian American adventure, Angelo N. Ancheta demonstrates how usa civil rights legislation were framed via a black-white version of race that sometimes ignores the reviews of different teams, together with Asian american citizens. whilst racial discourse is restricted to antagonisms among black and white, Asian american citizens usually locate themselves in a racial limbo, marginalized or unrecognized as complete members.

Judging Social Rights

International locations that now give some thought to constitutional reform frequently grapple with the query of no matter if to constitutionalize social rights. This booklet provides a controversy for why, below the ideal stipulations, doing so could be a good distance to enhance social justice. In making any such case, the writer considers the character of the social minimal, the position of courts between different associations, the empirical checklist of judicial impression, and the function of constitutional textual content.

Extra info for Universal Rights and the Constitution

Sample text

Universal Arguments and the Judiciary We can apprehend this difficulty as presented to the justices by recognizing judicial review as an innovative twist to a largely Lockean framework. In Locke’s account, a government lost legitimacy by transgressing natural rights, but the people had to determine whether the violations were serious enough to warrant the government’s dissolution. The framework provided no institutional check allowing for the redress of abuses short Universal Arguments in American Constitutionalism 23 of overthrowing the regime.

If natural law reasoning of any kind is unacceptable, then demonstrating its presence in a judicial opinion is to convict it of illegitimacy. Regardless of whether one approves, however, universal arguments in fact have occupied a significant place in constitutional jurisprudence. Thus, it is important 27 28 Universal Rights and the Constitution to consider not just when, but also how, the justices have used such arguments. The examination below focuses on whether justices defending universal arguments have used them in a manner that makes clear the role they are supposed to play in justifying decisions.

However, in discussing these objective considerations, the justices have leaned on precisely the kinds of considerations, such as history and predominant 36 Universal Rights and the Constitution public understandings, which would seem to prevent universal arguments from acting as the independent check that they have insisted is essential. Thus, the justices defending universal arguments have failed to provide an explanation of how judicial interpretation can be at once dependent on history and independent of it.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.44 of 5 – based on 19 votes